Nineveh
Merely Christian
logos_x said:I do find disagreement. ...
Rabbinic teachings describe several different scenarios for what happens to the soul during this period All of them rectify serious flaws in the soul’s matrix.
The Purgatory of the Grave, or the Suffering of the Grave (hibbut ha-kever).
During this time, says the Zohar, “For seven days the soul goes to and fro from his house to his grave, and from his grave to his house, mourning for the body, as it is written: ‘His flesh shall suffer pain for him, and his soul shall mourn for it’ (Job 14:22).” (Zohar I, 218b)
Perdition, or gehinnom.
In Judaism, gehinnom or perdition differs greatly from the concept of hell as described in other major religious faiths. Gehinnom is seen as an intermediary stage where the soul is purified before attaining its next level of existence or eternal reward.
The righteous skip this period entirely as do martyrs. The Jewish concept of hell actually affords an opportunity for elevation of the soul. Of course, this does not mean that hell is a cup of tea. The metaphor of hell being a “consuming fire” is common to both Judaism and Christianity.
http://www.jewsforjudaism.org/web/essays/afterlife03.html
Gehinnom has its foundations in an actual place where a pagan cult conducted rituals that included burning children (see the description in II Kings 23:10 and Jeremiah 7:31). It was associated by Christ with the coming judgment of Israel
Oddly enough, you left out the other side of Sheol, that being Abraham's Bosom. I am glad you can see there is a difference between hell and the lake though, although I would say your take on the lake is a bit RCC. Since Jesus is the one who introduces that idea, I'm not really sure how deep you can trace the Jewish roots of it. Is it that you disagree there were two parts to Sheol? Since that is what the first part of this convo is about. Sheol aka the grave.
Appears so.
Logos, now you agree. So which is it? Do you agree or not? Why is this like pulling teeth? Either we do have the place of "Sheol" aka the grave and it had two sides (hell + AB) and the lake aka "gehenna" aka the "garbage dump" or we don't and you take issue.
I do not know how to make the question any easier for you. People only get to die to the flesh once. What do they die to the second time?I'm not dodging, I answered the questions you asked based on what you asked.
If you want a different answer perhaps it would be fruitful to rephrase the question rather than continually asking the same thing and expecting a different answer.
Your problem is, you don't recognize what it means to be in subjection to Christ.
This is another rabbit trail. So all I'm going to reply to this is, "Your problem is, you don't recognize what it means to be in subjection to Christ."
Fire is associated with the Spirit more often than any other metephore used in scripture. It is even said that God, the Creator, IS a consuming fire.
It seems strange at first glance to our western perspective that a consuming fire creates everything that is. Fire is dangerous if not in control. But we in modern times have learned that fire is very useful when in the proper hands and in control.
Brimstone is a very interesting word in the greek, and it isn't just thrown in there with nothing to offer us I don't think. According to Thayer's Greek Definitions the word is:
θεῖον
theion
Thayer Definition:
1) brimstone
1a) divine incense, because burning brimstone was regarded as having power to purify, and to ward off disease
Part of Speech: noun neuter
A Related Word by Thayer’s/Strong’s Number: probably of G2304 (in its original sense of flashing)
G2304
θεῖος
theios
Thayer Definition:
1) a general name of deities or divinities as used by the Greeks
2) spoken of the only and true God, trinity
2a) of Christ
2b) Holy Spirit
2c) the Father
Part of Speech: adjective
A Related Word by Thayer’s/Strong’s Number: from G2316
G2316
θεός
theos
Thayer Definition:
1) a god or goddess, a general name of deities or divinities
2) the Godhead, trinity
2a) God the Father, the first person in the trinity
2b) Christ, the second person of the trinity
2c) Holy Spirit, the third person in the trinity
3) spoken of the only and true God
3a) refers to the things of God
3b) his counsels, interests, things due to him
4) whatever can in any respect be likened unto God, or resemble him in any way
4a) God’s representative or viceregent
4a1) of magistrates and judges
Part of Speech: noun masculine
A Related Word by Thayer’s/Strong’s Number: of uncertain affinity; a deity, especially (with G3588) the supreme Divinity
I view the second death as a refiners fire, and in the control of Jesus Christ. It has purpose inline with God's goals to be all in all.
Once that purpose has accomplished what He desires no one will be in it anymore. That purpose is to purify and make new the ones thrown in it.
Fire is also used to show destruction, as in the earth will be consumed with fire, or the pagans making their children pass through fire, which God never told people to do. Like most other things, "what you think" becomes your hermeneutic. Jesus does not speak of the "garbage dump" as a place of refinement but as a place the garbage gets dumped to burn. How often is garbage purified?
The metaphorical "fire and brimstone" tells us it is not just punitive, but also corrective and remedial. It therefore cannot be eternal unless it never accomplishes what is intended, which I think will be quite impossible.
Unless we look at it from the perspective Christ taught it to us in Mark 9. There is no mention of "only for a while". It really could be the "purpose" of the garbage dump is to put garbage in. Said another way, those that do not want to be with God have a place to be away from God.
Me? Pompous?
The thread is here. After pages of trying to get you to even attempt to reply, it was rather presumptuous of you to imply I don't really know what's going on. So if you want to keep that attitude, it just makes you look silly, no skin off my nose, I'll just reply to the pertinent points of your posts.