Who are you to judge what is or is not genuine repentance? I'll ask again seeing you don't seem to want to back up your notions with anything substantial:
How do you know that people faced with punishment are not genuine in any repentance they might show?
No, the issue is exactly that. What would you do if a man raped your wife:
A) Love him like you think Jesus would.
B) Want him executed like I think Jesus would want.
Do you have any answers tucked away inside your tiny brain? Or are you just going to spout cliche?
Who are you to say that someone is better off dead or that salvation is all that matters? Simply claiming to be a disciple of Christ does not give you free reign to impose your will on others.
The issue is that I am an imperfect man. What I desire isn't necessarily what is right. Therefore what I might want to do to someone who offends me or my family is irrelevant.
If someone rapes my wife. I would like to see justice served. In most cases of rape, I would not consider death justice. Death for some acts would be an injustice. But if Bob wants to be punished for his child abuse and sexual impurity, I'm sure he can find someone with a millstone. He doesn't need to impose his sick views on others just so he can forgive himself for his abominations.
"But I say unto you, Love your enemies, bless them that curse you, do good to them that hate you, and pray for them which despitefully use you, and persecute you"