I asked you:
Which of the following two mutually-contradictory propositions is the true one, and which is the false one?
- The referent of the word 'God' in John 4:24 is a HOLY Spirit.
- The referent of the word 'God' in John 4:24 is an UNHOLY Spirit.
Which proposition is the TRUE one? 1 or 2?
Which proposition is the FALSE one? 1 or 2?
Here is how you reacted to my question:
Neither of your answers are correct.
Here, you, once again, show yourself to be an abject fool who despises logic. You can war against the law of the excluded middle all you want, but you will only be further showing your stupidity.
EITHER the referent of the word 'God' in John 4:24 is holy, OR the referent of the word 'God' in John 4:24 is unholy. There's no ducking that fact. Since Jesus, in John 4:24, states that the referent of the word 'God' is a Spirit, the question is unavoidable: IS that Spirit--which John tells us God is--HOLY, or NOT?
I affirm that that Spirit IS HOLY; why do you refuse to do so?
Saying "Neither of your answers are correct" is nothing but YOU STONEWALLING, as usual. And, of course, you stonewall, here,
because you are desperately loath to NOT affirm that the Spirit that Jesus says YHWH
is is HOLY.
Also, you not once showed me verses that expresses the HS is YHWH, where in the said verses did it express to the HS as being YHWH, please show me.
Here, you not only deny that the referent of the word 'God', in John 4:24, is HOLY, but you are denying that the referent of the word 'God', in John 4:24, is YHWH!
Also, your argument of semantics of using John 4:24 is extremely deceitful and destroys the context of John.
In a dispute about the MEANING of something, only really, really
stupid people try to use the term "semantics" in a pejorative way against their opponents, like you are doing, here. See,
semantics is ALL ABOUT MEANING! Since it is customary for YOU, as a matter of course, throughout all of your posts, to pile up all manner of
meaningless nonsense, gibberish, gobbledygook, and mumbo-jumbo, why, OBVIOUSLY you are going to be sore about those who come along and embarrass you by asking you what (if anything) you mean! That's what semantics is: trying to find out the MEANINGS of things. Now, since you clearly specialize in writing meaningless tripe, while hoping that people will be bamboozled into thinking that the meaningless tripe you write is really
meaningful, OF COURSE you are going to get hot under the collar when I ask you what (if anything) you mean. You're trying to hide the fact that you have NO HOPE of giving a rational account about the things you write.
As we can see by the context the Father is the one who is being spoken of, he is the God mentioned in John 4:24. Thus, when you say is the 'God' in John 4:42 a Holy spirit or Un-holy spirit you ignore that it is the Father being spoken of as the God in v24.
Do you not think that, in John 4:24, Jesus is talking about YHWH? And, what does Jesus say about YHWH? He says that YHWH is a Spirit. So, again, the question is: Is YHWH, about Whom Jesus is saying "God is a Spirit", HOLY? Yes or No? If YHWH is a Spirit, and if YHWH is Holy, then YHWH is a Holy Spirit. But YOU deny that YHWH is a Holy Spirit! Astounding.
The "spirit" mentioned in John 4:24 is speaking about bodily composition
Did your Watchtower Society programmers/handlers teach you
that? It's nowhere in the Holy Bible, of course. Perhaps you got it from your
New World "Translation", your non-Bible.
The verse is saying "God is a Spirit" not "God is the Holy spirit", hence why many translations have the wording "God is a spirit" in John 4:24.
You agree that God is a Spirit, and you BLASPHEME God by denying that God is a HOLY Spirit. To DENY that God is a HOLY Spirit, while AFFIRMING that God is a Spirit, is to AFFIRM that God is an UNHOLY Spirit. That's what you are doing: you are claiming that God is an UNHOLY Spirit.
Angels are called "spirits" (Hebrews 1:7) "he [God] says about the angels: “He makes his angels spirits", since they are Holy does this make them holy spirits?
You really have to ask that question? YES! OF COURSE that makes them holy spirits! Anything that is both a spirit and holy is a holy spirit. Seriously, do you
disagree?
Your entire argument of semantics where you try and force the word "holy" onto the word Spirit in John 4:24 is poor.
Here, again, you are DENYING that YHWH is HOLY.
Romans 8:11 proves nothing in regards to what you said, where does the verse express that the Spirit was YHWH?
Where it says "the Spirit of him that raised up Jesus from the dead". Where else? Do you deny that YHWH is "him that raised up Jesus from the dead"? As we saw in John 4:24, YHWH is a Spirit. What OTHER Spirit would Paul be talking about if
not the Spirit that YHWH is?
And show me a verse that states YHWH is NOT a Giant Spaghetti monster!?
I do not know to what (if anything) you are referring by the phrase "a Giant Spaghetti monster". Are you referring to something by it? If so, to
what?
Now, try answering the question I asked you:
SINCE the referent of the word 'God' in John 4:24 is--according to John 4:24--A SPIRIT, consider the two propositions:
- The referent of the word 'God' in John 4:24 is a HOLY Spirit.
- The referent of the word 'God' in John 4:24 is an UNHOLY Spirit.
Which proposition is the TRUE one? 1 or 2?
Which proposition is the FALSE one? 1 or 2?