An Appeal To Intellectual Vigor
An Appeal To Intellectual Vigor
Hi quasi,
Welcome!
She cannot help who she loves anymore than we can, and to try to change someones very basic desires is to bring about pain and ignore the very essence of our humanity, to love.
Well, the first chapter in Leanne Payne's
The Broken Image is about a woman she counselled. Entirely lesbian, no heterosexual desires. "Born" that way, it would seem.
Turns out this woman had no memories between ~2-5 years of age. She was enabled to revisit this period of her life. At the age of three, Lisa was sexually molested by her father (who forced her to have oral sex with him). They were caught by her mother who screamed. When Lisa went toward her mother to console her, her mother pushed her away.
Lisa is now heterosexual and I, for one, thank God that someone tried to help her in terms of "who she could love."
Obviously, because of your basenote, I am not here to appeal to you spiritually, but I am here to appeal to you intellectually.
1) If a premise is clearly known to NOT be universally true, it is rather difficult to maintain it must be true for specific cases.
I apply #1 to:
The concept that "I was always this way" being equivalent to "I was born this way."
I also apply it to:
One cannot and ought not "change" who one loves.
Now, I can almost anticipate that you would take the above example as some severe, highly peculiar example and thus deny its possible applicability to anyone else. But, I think this would be far too simplistic a tack to take. Human behavior is very complex and has many possibilities. I think a more intelligent course would be to leave that forum open to other possibilities, than the narrow-minded, dogmatic mantra
I was born this way.
Lisa was not.
Aqua, I was once very, very much on the side of homosexual orientation. Consider the analogy of a stream, rushing unimpeded in a certain direction (sexual expression where there is no brokenness) and another stream, whose direction is skewed by the presence of rocks. I have had three or four rocks identified. Rocks being areas of brokenness.
I know too many people, including myself, who are "reorientated."
Consider the following as a "physical realm" analogy. Sometimes people always had a health condition and never even knew it. After they no longer had the health condition, they couldn't believe how much better they felt.
I can't call unwellness, wellness.
Tony (o2)