Oppress gays if they don't comply? Comply with what? Not engaging in behavior that is illegal?
And who says it should be illegal, you and your buddies?
Want your cake and eat it much do you?
I'm not gay but you'd only have your way over my dead body I can assure you.
Do we likewise oppress everyone who does anything else we've outlawed? Aren't they also failing to comply and wouldn't that also make all of us in favor of any law at all oppressors?
Who else exactly does the state outlaw for doing in private what is simply a natural preference for them? Which after all has no actual difference, in effect, from hetrosexual sex as far as the non concerned are concerned, and is of particularly of no concern to the state imo.
I do however try to understand how your own religious views make this hard for you to accept, which is where some tolerance for other people's own views would come in handy perhaps. But sadly I rather suspect that your world is far too black and white for that.
I think you have no argument here and you know it. Else you wouldn't pretend on this one issue that a majority ruling is somehow oppression.
Nonsense, there is no pretence involved, do you actually believe that a majority can't oppress a minority, when clearly even the largest minority can do that in a democracy?
Do you really think that a majority opinion is automatically the right and proper position?
You'd not have your way in my society without a physical fight I can assure you because I for one am never going to accept gays being locked up or executed in my name just having gay sex in private, or indeed that they be forced not to just to suit the likes of you.
Again, would you call every instance where the majority ruled democratically to legislate for/against something contrary to the will of the minority oppression? Or is it that the majority ruling to outlaw this one behavior against an opposing minority that's somehow oppressive?
Maybe you can explain why this would be oppressive and any other majority ruling is not?
If the civil secular laws offend me enough then it really doesn't actually matter if it's called democracy or not on your particular
ship of fools.
You know, the only way out of this is to fall back to pretending we're advocating outlawing homosexuality, rather than homosexual sex. Like Lightbringer's left-handed thing, fr'nstance. Go ahead if you like. I'll consider that a win, as always. :idunno:
I'm really not "in" anything Mary except in your own mind perhaps.
You are perfectly within your rights as a human being to not like homosexuals or what they do in private, but you have no right to stop them doing it in private, even if the thought of what they do deeply offends you or only because you happen to think from religious dogma that it offends your God.