What I'm seeing in new Orleans is what I believe to be an endemic problem being brought to light by extraordinary circumstances. As long as all these poor people were tucked away in their run-down neighborhoods, mostly praying on each other, and willing to accept the pittance we give them in leu of a real job (that we will not give them) then we could pretty much pretend that they don't exist, and that they don't resent our laws and our police and our white faces and our whole social structure for what we've been doing to them.
mostly praying on each other (I gather this means stealing and hurting one another to somehow get what they think they want)
that they don't resent our laws and our police and our white faces and our whole social structure for what we've been doing to them.
We can spew platitudes about pulling ourselves up by the bootstraps and all that and we can ignore the fact that we wouldn't even let them have the boots.
I do agree with you – that there are files kept on people by certain concealed groups – even making files on grade 3 students – but this is not the Government nor us. It is possible for a very small percent of the population to do a whole lot of social engineering – but it is not the government nor social system.We ignore the fact that our whole government and social system in this country is intent on helping the "right people" get rich, and stay rich, while just placating and exploiting everyone else.
Then something like this disaster comes, and strips away our pretty facade of freedom and justice and fairness, and we're forced to see what our system has really been doing to people, and what they have become as a result. And we REALLY don't want to be seeing this. We really don't want to see that the reason we have so much is because so many others have so little.
And we really don't want to see that we're no more deserving of what we have then they are. So we do what we've always done. We hate them. We hate them for representing the fruits of our own greed. And we blame their suffering on them, so we can pretend it's not our fault. We even tell ourselves that it's good that they suffer, that it will teach them to be stonger and to become aggressive and greedy (we call it "hard-working") like us. But even when they do, we still don't like 'em. We still don't want them around. They still remind us of our own selfishness. This is especially true of people of color. Just their physical appearance reminds us of what an unfair advantage we've had, and how we don't really deserve to have so much more just because we're white.
They still remind us of our own selfishness. This is especially true of people of color. Just their physical appearance reminds us of what an unfair advantage we've had, and how we don't really deserve to have so much more just because we're white
I think sums up your post – as it is you who is doing this wallowing in filth – and I hope you do not do as what you perceive your fellow citizens are going to doI think it's good that America is finally getting to see it's own citizens wallowing in filth and greed and lawlessness.
Take a good look. I'm sure PureX will be sweeping it under the rug just as soon as he can.
Please understand that this problem is now endemic. We have created generations (ie: a whole sub-culture) of people who are convinced that they're locked out of the the nation's economy as a whole, for life. There will be no convincing many of them otherwise, at this point, and were we to have experienced what they've experienced we would be no different. And there will be no way of changing the violent and self-destructive response to this hopelessness that some have fallen into, either. What has been done has been done. But we can at least be honest enough to admit that much of what has been done, has been done by our own greed and prejudice as much as by the failing of others.servent101 said:PureX
How do you provide a job for people if they as you say are prone to: "mostly praying on each other" (I gather this means stealing and hurting one another to somehow get what they think they want)?
Yes, there are. But we make it so ridiculously difficult that only a few will have the strength and determination and ability and luck to make it out. The rest will give up in the face of such constant negation, and they will fall pray to all the usual problems that come with chronic poverty. And all it's so unnecessary. It's the result of nothing but stupid, blind, fear and prejudice.servent101 said:And as far as "... that they ... resent our laws and our police and our white faces and our whole social structure for what we've been doing to them". Well they are free to read – and there are libraries, and there are people who crawl out of that lifestyle – both black and white.
The "school of hard knocks" will inspire some to try harder, and to be tougher (which can have very bad effects of it's own later on) but it will also destroy many. This is not an abstract discussion, people suffer and die horribly every day in this country from grinding poverty. The "bootstrap school of hard knocks" platitudes are not changing this reality at all. In fact all they do is give the people who are responsible for much of this suffering a pathetic excuse to blame their victims; one that they latch onto tenaciously and reiterate over and over and over again, not surprisingly. Maybe if they say it enough times they'll even manage to convince themselves of it. But it's BS. And it always was.servent101 said:This is somewhat true – people need “something”… but to some degree it is the school of hard knocks that helps people to decide to find another “way” at looking at life and doing what they have done in the past.
I wasn't referring to any secret conspiracies or covert social engineering. I was referring to how the people in power in business are of the same race, creed, and social classes as the people in government, and how every decision they make, consciously and unconsciously is designed to keep them in these positions of power, and to keep everyone else out. And the more "different" you are from "them", the more obstacles they will put between you and those positions of power. Skin color seems to weigh in heavily as a "difference", which is why so many European "outsiders" have eventually been let into the power elite while people of color remain locked out.servent101 said:I do agree with you – that there are files kept on people by certain concealed groups – even making files on grade 3 students – but this is not the Government nor us. It is possible for a very small percent of the population to do a whole lot of social engineering – but it is not the government nor social system.
Of course it's the poor who are doing the looting. They have the most need, and the most resentment against the system that has helped to keep them poor all their lives, and they have the least respect for this system's laws - especially property laws. The rich don't loot because they already own everything they need, and they know they can always get more. The property laws are designed to help them keep what they already have. Why should someone who has nothing and knows that they never will have anything care about the protection of property? And the fact that so many of the poor are also black, is the evidence of American racism staring us all right in the face. And just look at us all squirming and blaming and making excuses; trying to ignore the obvious.servent101 said:yes there are a lot of people who have so little – but if you look at percentages – almost ¾ of the people in America have their own homes or are in the process of making mortgage payments …. As far as the looters –most likely less that ½ of 1% of the people will be doing the looting – but since there is a few million people there – that one half of one per-cent does seem to be a lot of people.
I agree that we are our own worst enemies, but when we're also the power elite, our flaws destroy other people, instead of ourselves. So I'm not going to allow personal weakness as an excuse for people who hold the economic and political power. They wanted the power, they wanted the wealth, and they knew they didn't deserve it any more than anyone else. Yet they hoarded it and protected it for themselves, and shut everyone else out as best they could. They have no excuse for the harm they've done to others. And to the extent that we support them, we have no excuse, either.servent101 said:So what you say is true… it is just not representing the majority of people – and for most people regardless of race or gender our worst enemies are ourselves. If we could only learn how to deal with our lives in some sort of cognitive positive self talk and gain a little wisdom and knowledge what barriers are ahead of us individually would be easily overcome.
This is what I want Americans to see in this disaster ... themselves. Those people suffering from this disaster are us. They are our responsibility, both good and bad. We created New Orleans. The hurricane just stripped away the pretty facade that's been hiding what we've been doing behind it.
is just a hog wash - black wash (the opposite of white washing something) of the actual reality - and unfortunately anyone who believes you is probably going to take this as career advice anyways - how to get ahead in life... and then they go out and do those dispicable acts to your credit - and to credit of people who spout the same synical perspectives.So I'm not going to allow personal weakness as an excuse for people who hold the economic and political power. They wanted the power, they wanted the wealth, and they knew they didn't deserve it any more than anyone else. Yet they hoarded it and protected it for themselves, and shut everyone else out as best they could. They have no excuse for the harm they've done to others. And to the extent that we support them, we have no excuse, either.
you don't do anything to suggest how and what we as people, black white or yellow, can do to stop being our own worst enemies - instead you give a good example of what people who are their own worst enemies believe about society - they simply black wash everything, and yes some do white wash everything - but the truth is not as you "paint it". Yes there are some as you say - but they are few, and if someone believes the whole world is like that - they will subconsciously make their expectations come true. Their is something to be said for consistency in society - but in the 1900's this was more of a problem, but today we are becoming a more progressive society and concepts like your preach simply are not that predominant anymore. Yes there is "some" of what you say happening - but I disagree on the extent of the problem. The world is getting smaller and smaller and the sooner we start to realize how to make that 97% of the brain that we do not use work for us the better. These people who are Black are at an advantage... they know they have to be smarter, faster, wiser and knowledgeable than the ordinary person - but who tells them that? - Not you... you just make the matter worse by saying that there is no way out for most of the Black people. The more people like you they have in their corner - the worse they are off.I agree that we are our own worst enemies
Gaviidae said:Reading some more, it would appear that 98% of the residents of the worst damaged area were blacks. That would certainly account for the lack of diversity amongst the evacuees, especially in the news footage. Certainly makes more sense than all poor people in New Orleans are black so the only people left behind were black.
PureX said:Right. Now, how do you explain the fact that 98% of the poorest people in New Orleans were black, when black people only make up 67% of the total population?
PureX said:Any way that doesn't threaten the comfort zone of the white people in power. Mostly it means dress, talk, think, and act unthreateningly "like your white bosses want you to act". You know, like Colin Powell or Condi Rice. Most black people can't or won't do that, and we fear and resent them because of it.
BillyBob said:The looting part of this story is unbelievable.
So the question is, should they bother rebuilding New Orleans? It's just gonna happen again....and again....
docrob57 said:Yeah gee, it's happened so many times before. Like . . . . . ?
docrob57 said:Yeah gee, it's happened so many times before. Like . . . . . ?
BillyBob said:Here is a link for Glenn Beck's website, he has quite a few articles [a couple dozen or so] on Katrine linked there. It's convenient.
There are articles about looting, suicides, transporting survivors to the Houston Astrodome, oil business etc.
http://www.glennbeck.com/page2/index.shtml
:shocked: Actually I had no idea who he was until a co-worker told me about him about 6 months ago. He is a conservative radio talk show host. I've only listened to him briefly a few times, but he seems pretty entertaining.Jujubee said:I am sorry who is Glenn Beck?
Army of One said::shocked: Actually I had no idea who he was until a co-worker told me about him about 6 months ago. He is a conservative radio talk show host. I've only listened to him briefly a few times, but he seems pretty entertaining.
Gaviidae said:Like in 1965. But more importantly, do you think this will never happen again? Hurricanes will no longer appear in the coast and the Mississippi will remain in it's banks?
Fact is, hurricanes that would have as much if not more destructive power to New Orleans come very close every decade. In the past, they've missed. Even Katrina actually missed. But someday one will hit just right. And that'll be nothing compared to Katrina.
Out here we have something you've probably heard of; Mt. St. Helens. It exploded 25 years ago. It happened last 3,000 years ago. Less time than the last time a hurrican blew through New Orleans. Yet, we have not built around the blast zone. Aruments like yours could say it's only happened once and we could build homes all over the blast zone. But luckily, there are people with more sense. It may be 3,000 more years before the next blast or it may be 3. But whatever it is, it will happen again and we shouldn't rebuild there.
I've heard it will cost $15+ billion to protect New Orleans. That's a lot of money for what has become a minor city.