Lately, I've mentioned the Electric Universe Theory in several of my posts and I've been thinking about starting a thread to introduce the theory to more people and to discuss the topic in more detail but haven't been able to decide how best to start. Then the folks over at The Thunderbolts Project website provided the perfect starting point for my new thread. They regularly publish YouTube videos on a wide variety of topics related to the Electric Universe Theory (EUT or just EU for short) and they've begun a series of ten videos that each present what they consider to be the best points in favor of accepting the EU. So far, they've put out the first two of these ten videos and I wanted to present them here for everyone's consideration.
As for me, while I'm not apposed in general to the gist of the EUT, I cannot be considered a full-blown proponent of the theory. I can readily accept the notion that electromagnetic forces play a much bigger role than the standard model would suggest or even permit and I have long understood that mainstream science has been politicized and corrupted into something that cannot be rightly considered scientific and that what is left of the scientific community is entrenched into a mindset that puts as much or more emphasis on their mathematical models as they do onto actual observational, experimental science. Even their experiments are formulated on the basis of fundamentally mathematical concepts of the way the universe works and are analyzed on that same basis. They are so up past their noses in mathematics that they cannot see the circularity of their cosmological arguments and are blind to falsifying observational data. I have no doubt that before this series of videos is complete, you'll hear quite a lot about these issues.
The parts of the EUT that I can't swallow have to do with what some of their main people have to say about the positions of the planets and how they've changed dramatically in the last several thousand years and that this explains ancient belief systems, etc. It all starts to sound a lot like the idiotic television show called "Ancient Aliens". For this reason, as well as the fact that I've had very little exposure to the EUT other than YouTube videos, I can't personally endorse the theory. I do however think that large portions of it are worth serious consideration.
Now, what I'd like is some serious discussion on the topic. Meaning that I invite real criticism, debate and substantive discussion of both the pros and cons of the theory. I'm not at all interested in ridicule and name-calling, although I know that some of you won't be capable of resisting such behavior. You should know that the people behind this theory are NOT Christians and the EU is NOT some sort of alternative cosmology designed to agree with a biblical worldview. In fact, the "insert a miracle here" mentality is one of Walt Thornhill's biggest complaints about the Standard Model and the Big Bang Theory.
Finally, if you want to participate in the thread, you gotta actually watch the videos. It's going to be really easy to tell whether you've watched them or not so please don't waste everyone's time by trying to get away with having not watched them. If you want to post another video in either support of or opposition to the EUT then please write a short synopsis of the video just to give the gist of the argument presented. Just a sentence or two to let everyone know that you've watched the video and that it's pertinent to the discussion.
I'll post the first two videos in two separate posts to as to make them easier to respond to individually.
Clete
P.S. I've decided to also put a link to each video at the bottom of this post so that they are all easy to find...
Top 10 Reasons the Universe is Electric: #1 Cosmic Magnetic Fields (Post#2)
Top 10 Reasons the Universe is Electric: #2 Filaments in Space (Post#3)
Top 10 Reasons the Universe is Electric: #3 Cosmic Jets (Post #17)
Top 10 Reasons the Universe is Electric: #4 Light Bulbs in Space (Post #209)
Top 10 Reasons the Universe is Electric #5: Pulsars (Post 231)
Top 10 Reasons the Universe is Electric #6: Charged Planets (Inner Solar System) (Post 244)
Top 10 Reasons the Universe is Electric #7: Charged Planets (Outer Solar System) (Post 246)
Top 10 Reasons the Universe is Electric #8: Electrical Planetary Scarring (Post 252)
As for me, while I'm not apposed in general to the gist of the EUT, I cannot be considered a full-blown proponent of the theory. I can readily accept the notion that electromagnetic forces play a much bigger role than the standard model would suggest or even permit and I have long understood that mainstream science has been politicized and corrupted into something that cannot be rightly considered scientific and that what is left of the scientific community is entrenched into a mindset that puts as much or more emphasis on their mathematical models as they do onto actual observational, experimental science. Even their experiments are formulated on the basis of fundamentally mathematical concepts of the way the universe works and are analyzed on that same basis. They are so up past their noses in mathematics that they cannot see the circularity of their cosmological arguments and are blind to falsifying observational data. I have no doubt that before this series of videos is complete, you'll hear quite a lot about these issues.
The parts of the EUT that I can't swallow have to do with what some of their main people have to say about the positions of the planets and how they've changed dramatically in the last several thousand years and that this explains ancient belief systems, etc. It all starts to sound a lot like the idiotic television show called "Ancient Aliens". For this reason, as well as the fact that I've had very little exposure to the EUT other than YouTube videos, I can't personally endorse the theory. I do however think that large portions of it are worth serious consideration.
Now, what I'd like is some serious discussion on the topic. Meaning that I invite real criticism, debate and substantive discussion of both the pros and cons of the theory. I'm not at all interested in ridicule and name-calling, although I know that some of you won't be capable of resisting such behavior. You should know that the people behind this theory are NOT Christians and the EU is NOT some sort of alternative cosmology designed to agree with a biblical worldview. In fact, the "insert a miracle here" mentality is one of Walt Thornhill's biggest complaints about the Standard Model and the Big Bang Theory.
Finally, if you want to participate in the thread, you gotta actually watch the videos. It's going to be really easy to tell whether you've watched them or not so please don't waste everyone's time by trying to get away with having not watched them. If you want to post another video in either support of or opposition to the EUT then please write a short synopsis of the video just to give the gist of the argument presented. Just a sentence or two to let everyone know that you've watched the video and that it's pertinent to the discussion.
I'll post the first two videos in two separate posts to as to make them easier to respond to individually.
Clete
P.S. I've decided to also put a link to each video at the bottom of this post so that they are all easy to find...
Top 10 Reasons the Universe is Electric: #1 Cosmic Magnetic Fields (Post#2)
"This episode marks the beginning of a special 10-part series, "Top 10 Reasons the Universe is Electric." In this first chapter, we explore the significance of the astrophysical enigma of pervasive cosmic magnetic fields. Basic physics classes teach that electric currents produce magnetic fields. But why is this law of physics almost nowhere evident in the standard astrophysical literature? Plasma physics and electrical engineering hold the key to explaining the origins of powerful magnetic fields throughout the cosmos."
Top 10 Reasons the Universe is Electric: #2 Filaments in Space (Post#3)
"Electric currents flowing through space plasmas can be recognized through their distinct filamentary shape. With remarkable advances in space telescopes, we see today in unprecedented detail filamentary structures that pervade the visible universe at all scales. The appearances of these unique structures have proved puzzling far more often than not to astronomers. In this episode, we explore why filamentation throughout the cosmos is just one of ten reasons why the Universe is electric."
Top 10 Reasons the Universe is Electric: #3 Cosmic Jets (Post #17)
"It is a mystery that space science must confront: What force is capable of producing high-energy jets spanning not millions of miles, but many light-years across the cosmos? What confines the jets to narrow streams across cosmic distances, and what prevents the so-called streams of gas from dispersing in the “vacuum” of space? We explore this question and more in part three of our ongoing video series, "Top Ten Reasons the Universe is Electric.""
Top 10 Reasons the Universe is Electric: #4 Light Bulbs in Space (Post #209)
In Number 4 of our ongoing series, "The Top Ten Reasons the Universe is Electric," we explore an ongoing astrophysical enigma -- the Fermi Bubbles, giant gamma ray structures which scientists have dubbed "incandescent bulbs screwed into the center of the galaxy." In this episode, we explore why such a feature is both explicable and predictable in the Electric Universe.
Top 10 Reasons the Universe is Electric #5: Pulsars (Post 231)
One of the strangest hypothetical astrophysical objects is called a neutron star. Scientists tell us that the material leftover from a supernova explosion of a massive star collapses gravitationally, forming an incredibly small yet massively dense star mostly composed of tightly packed neutrons. A rotating neutron star is said to emit narrow beams of radiation, called pulsars. But the theoretical and evidential objections to this hypothesis are numerous. In this episode we explore the promising theoretical alternatives in the disciplines of plasma physics and electrical engineering.
Top 10 Reasons the Universe is Electric #6: Charged Planets (Inner Solar System) (Post 244)
In the first five installments of this series, we outlined some of the most compelling evidence that the role of electromagnetism throughout the cosmos is vastly more significant than modern space science has ever entertained. So far, we have explored this question through an examination of the highest energy electromagnetic phenomena at the vastest scales throughout the cosmos. We now move our attention to our own celestial neighborhood and the dynamic interactions between the Sun and all of the bodies which move within its electrical domain. In this episode, we explore why planetary electrical discharge — beginning with planets in the inner solar system — are the sixth of ten reasons why the universe is electric.
Top 10 Reasons the Universe is Electric #7: Charged Planets (Outer Solar System) (Post 246)
In this series, we have presented evidence for a dramatically new way of viewing all celestial bodies. In an Electric Universe, nowhere can one find an “island in space.” Across vast cosmic distances, electric currents flow through the conductive medium of plasma, electromagnetically pinching gas and dust to form stars and planets. In our last episode, we focused on the electrical circuitry in our own celestial neighborhood in the inner solar system, connecting the Sun to all the planets, including the Earth. Today, we shift our focus to the outer solar system, where the tremendous electrified environments of the gas giants Saturn and Jupiter are the 7th of 10 reasons why the Universe is Electric.
Top 10 Reasons the Universe is Electric #8: Electrical Planetary Scarring (Post 252)
We have created this special top-ten series to highlight the most compelling evidence for the dominant role of electromagnetism at all scales throughout the cosmos. The experimentally proven ability of high energy electrical discharges to produce craters and countless other planetary features offers an entirely new perspective on planetary science and the solar system’s history. In this episode, we explore why the high-energy electrical scarring of bodies in our solar system is the eighth of ten reasons why the Universe is Electric.
Last edited: