I thought Dr. Carhart's clinic was still shut down for repair after the fire.
So yes, women looking to kill their baby in the third trimester will be having trouble finding someone to do the job.
George Tillers Abortion Clinic Closed - for good.
- Thread starter Nathon Detroit
- Start date
I thought Dr. Carhart's clinic was still shut down for repair after the fire.
So yes, women looking to kill their baby in the third trimester will be having trouble finding someone to do the job.
WizardofOz
New member
PLGW mentioned a third.
Tiller's clinic closing will create a vacuum of sorts. I figure it will only be a short time before someone fills it. It's big business after all.
Tiller killed 60,000 people.
He killed them the week before he died and he was gonna kill the week after he died, but he couldn't because he was dead.
This is justifiable homicide pure and simple.
Wouldn't that be a hoot huh? instead of justices legislating from the bench the people could legislate from the jury box, "sure abortion is legal, go right ahead, but if you get shot the perp is only gonna do 90 days so have fun with that"
Maybe not now that the job is a little more like stepping in front of a fireing squad.
WizardofOz
New member
Your approval of this method is a slippery slope. The government is just waiting to label more groups as domestic terrorists. More acts like this and abortionists will be a protected group like homosexuals are now.
You'll win a battle and lose the war
Abortionists are a protected group already.
Didn't help in Tiller's case though :thumb:
WizardofOz
New member
Acts like this will only make matters worse in the long run.
Let’s take that apart as two assumptions; one being the death penalty; second, the method of the depth penalty and the suffering of the terminally ill.
The question on the method of punishment is what we have chosen, if one took a poll about making the death penalty quicker, it would not be passed even by the electorate. We are stuck with what we have, this is not a state where one believed to have committed the fatal crime gets a bullet in the head. Although he can choose it if he runs at many police officers with a gun.
The second part, those suffering from terminal illness, I think you will see that change in the next few years. Some will never opt for assisted suicide for religious reasons, but I believe many will, once painful death is enviable. I heard it argued many ways from persons wanting to escape pain to believing greedy physicians mainly desire to take one life savings which could go to their children. It seems like the option will continue to grow, but many will not think it is right for a manifold of reasons, as many will think it right for manifold reasons.
Therefore, one we are going to have to live with, but the other is not so firm.
assuranceagent
New member
Wiz...can I ask who you voted for in the presidential election?
WizardofOz
New member
I could care less how viable a candidate is. I now only vote (and I always vote) for the candidate who most closely reflects my beliefs and values.
assuranceagent
New member
Even if it means a potentially worse situation?
How is that any different from what fool is suggesting?
If you truly believe abortion is murder...
**btw, my little internal jury is still out on this one, I just think your reasoning above risks being inconsistent...
Yeah, actually, such women will have trouble...and considering that US Marshals are being used to protect clinics nationwide, I'd say this is already costing us money.
WizardofOz
New member
Holy bait and switch batman! Just kidding, I must have quoted you before you changed it (I do that all the time).
I was and am a very strong supporter of Ron Paul. He wasn't on the ballot obviously but he endorsed Chuck Baldwin. I voted for Baldwin after reviewing his issues.
here is Baldwin on abortion. Some great quotes.....
Baldwin favors overturning Roe v. Wade, noting the Republican Party is "phony" on the issue. "They have done nothing to stop abortion on demand, even though they had the entire federal government for six years," he said. "We feel that now the Republican Party is probably on the last legs of its existence."
Republicans tout themselves as being "pro-life." Yet, the GOP controlled both houses of Congress and the White House for six years and did absolutely nothing to overturn Roe or end abortion-on-demand. Under my administration, we could end legal abortion in a matter of days, not decades. And if Congress refused to pass Ron Paul's bill, I would use the constitutional power of the Presidency to deny funds to protect abortion clinics. Either way, legalized abortion ends when I take office.
A strongly religious man, Baldwin emphasized his belief in the right of all to choose the religion of their choice. He made note of his friendship and admiration for Roman Catholic Alan Keyes during his acceptance speech, mentioning that he had welcomed his opponent for the nomination to speak to his Baptist congregation. Perhaps the strongest of Baldwin's issues is the matter of abortion. He emphasized support for Ron Paul's "Sanctity of Life Act" (H.R. 2597) that declares human life "shall be deemed to exist from conception" and bars the Supreme Court from ruling on the matter. Once legally defined as a person, insisted Baldwin, every infant in the womb would thereby be guaranteed the right to life--under the U.S. Constitution. He thundered, "If the Republican Party had been serious about life, it could have already ended legal abortion in America."
I am glad he beat Keyes for the Constitution Party nomination.
| Baldwin on abortion | |
I hope Chrysostom watches this one.
| Baldwin on Paul's Sanctity of Life Act | |
WizardofOz
New member
How so? I should vote for McCain just so Obama doesn't become president? That is just giving support to a flawed system. The two are really not different in any significant way. If you believe they are, then I think you've just been fooled into thinking so.
I've done it in the past and will not do it again. I am not going to settle with my vote. If less viable candidates get a larger percentage of the vote, politicians are going to look at why they are. What issues are they finding support on?
Legally voting for a presidential candidate vs. killing an abortion doctor? You'll have to clarify the stretch you're making. I am not seeing the connection.
Are you questioning my belief?
How is it inconsistent?
Don't fight evil with evil. Tiller was a murderer. He was murdered by a murderer. Anyone who see's Roeder as a hero endorses vigilantism. It's not a very viable long term strategy and will undoubtedly hurt the pro-life movement long term more than help it.
Please articulate your point, I am not getting it. :idunno:
WizardofOz
New member
You all may be right about that, but I feel it's only temporary. As long as it's legal, someone will offer the service.
I am not really a relativist on the issue anyway. First trimester, third trimester, it's still the same end result.:idunno:
And after the Roeder incident, it will only cost more and more.
WizardofOz
New member
assuranceagent - can I ask you the same question?
Duh.