i. Pre-Fall man—posse peccare (the ability to sin) and posse non peccare
(the ability to not sin). Pelagius taught that this condition remains after
the Fall.
ii. Post-Fall man—non posse non peccare (the inability to not sin). This is
the moral condition of original sin.
Adam's "free will" consisted of the mutability, that is, the potentiality of obedience or disobedience. This is not libertarian free will, the liberty of indifference. Whatever Adam would do it was what he was most inclined to do when he did so do. Libertarian free will claims a choice bereft of want/inclination as if neutrality were possible in the will. This is nonsense and when we use terms like "free will" we need to define them beforehand so everyone is on the same page.
(the ability to not sin). Pelagius taught that this condition remains after
the Fall.
ii. Post-Fall man—non posse non peccare (the inability to not sin). This is
the moral condition of original sin.
Adam's "free will" consisted of the mutability, that is, the potentiality of obedience or disobedience. This is not libertarian free will, the liberty of indifference. Whatever Adam would do it was what he was most inclined to do when he did so do. Libertarian free will claims a choice bereft of want/inclination as if neutrality were possible in the will. This is nonsense and when we use terms like "free will" we need to define them beforehand so everyone is on the same page.