Why is gender a social construct, but not race?

Angel4Truth

New member
Hall of Fame
Rachel Dolezal disinvited from Baltimore Book Festival after public backlash

Published May 31, 2017
Fox News

Days after defending its decision to have Dolezal, the white woman who led others to believe she was black, take part in the Baltimore Book Festival, organizers say the former head of the Spokane chapter of the NAACP has been disinvited, Tuesday, May 30, 2017.

Days after defending its decision to have Dolezal, the white woman who led others to believe she was black, take part in the Baltimore Book Festival, organizers say the former head of the Spokane chapter of the NAACP has been disinvited, Tuesday, May 30, 2017. (Copyright 2017 The Associated Press. All rights reserved.)

Organizers for the Baltimore Book Festival announced Tuesday they disinvited Rachel Dolezal, the controversial white woman who represented herself as African American for years, to this year's event after receiving major public backlash.

Festival organizers released a statement on its Facebook page, citing reaction from attendees and authors as the reason for rescinding Dolezal's invitation.

"A top priority of the Baltimore Office of Promotion & The Arts is to listen to our constituents, and after hearing from a cross-section of opinions on having Rachel Dolezal participate in this year’s festival, we had to consider how her appearance may affect both the audience and the other extraordinary authors we have planned for the Baltimore Book Festival," the statement read.

"For that reason, we believe it is appropriate to remove Ms. Dolezal from the festival lineup," the statement concluded.

RACHEL DOLEZAL, WHITE WOMAN WHO IDENTIFIES AS BLACK, NOW JOBLESS, MAY SOON BE HOMELESS

Dolezal was initially invited to the September festival to read her autobiography, "In Full Color: Finding My Place in a Black and White World." Organizers initially defended their decision to have the controversial figure at the festival when it was first announced last week.

"The Baltimore Office of Promotion & the Arts does not agree or disagree with the many authors that have appeared on the festival’s stages for more than 20 years, but we do provide a platform for relevant and multi-layered conversations," they said in a statement posted last Thursday. The Baltimore Book Festival has hosted more than 3,000 writers in the past.

Many followers and attendees, however, were not pleased about the addition.

"Bad decision to include Dolezal," one woman said on Facebook.

"Rachel Dolezal is a big red flag. Not attending any event that she's been invited to. Are you paying her as well? I certainly hope not," another person said.

An online petition circulated soon after the announcement, calling the invite as "racially insensitive," according to The Baltimore Sun. The petition garnered more than 100 signatures by Tuesday morning.

"I saw it as a bad publicity stunt that was really hurtful to a community that has already suffered enough," petition organizer Kimberly Mooney told the newspaper.

Dolezal grabbed national attention in June 2015 when a local television crew asked her on camera if she was African American. Soon after, photos of Dolezal when she was young with pale skin and blonde hair surfaced. Dolezal was formerly the leader of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP) chapter in Spokane, Wash. She was also accused of falsifying multiple reports of hate crimes.

Dolezal revealed to The Guardian in February that she has been rejected for 100 jobs, only receiving offers to do reality TV and pornography films. Her autobiography was turned down by 30 publishers before someone accepted it.

Why is it ok for people to be like bruce jenner and be celebrated as heros those who claim they are an alternate gender than how they were born, yet this woman who claims to be black trapped in a white body, is to be scorned and rejected.

Whats the difference? If gender is a social construct and its acceptable to be other than how you were born (sex) than why isnt what shes claiming ok?

Who are you to say what she can identify as?

8049528_g4.jpg
 

quip

BANNED
Banned
Gays accept transgenders; blacks oppose the transraced (for lack of better term) :idunno:
 

MrDante

New member
Whats the difference? If gender is a social construct and its acceptable to be other than how you were born (sex) than why isnt what shes claiming ok?
Get your terms straight. Gender is not a social consstruct, gender IDENTITY is a social construct.
 

glassjester

Well-known member
Get your terms straight. Gender is not a social consstruct, gender IDENTITY is a social construct.

Maybe so, but isn't the demand that people with the "gender identity" of (for example) female be treated by everyone as if their gender was female?
 

Angel4Truth

New member
Hall of Fame
Maybe so, but isn't the demand that people with the "gender identity" of (for example) female be treated by everyone as if their gender was female?

He knows that and he knows there is no difference, if a man can identify as a woman, then a white woman can identify as a white woman, because its all how you feel, right?
 

glassjester

Well-known member
The question, I think, is not whether someone has the right to identify as anything. But whether it is reasonable to force others to agree with that self-identification.
 

Tambora

Get your armor ready!
LIFETIME MEMBER
Hall of Fame
It's strange that Quip says gays accept transgenders. Shouldn't the emphasis be on women accepting transgender women, and men accepting transgender men?
wonder what would happen if one from a couple of lezbos decides to be a man?
Does that mean neither of them are lezbos any more???
:think:
 

Tambora

Get your armor ready!
LIFETIME MEMBER
Hall of Fame
The question, I think, is not whether someone has the right to identify as anything. But whether it is reasonable to force others to agree with that self-identification.
Right.
I think the nuts SHOULD be laughed at and mocked for just being stupid.
 
Top