His first wife and fellow religious activist, Krista filed for divorce in 1989. While their marriage undoubtly suffered from their arrests and jail time as a result of 'Operation Rescue', Enyart has claimed it ended due to his own struggles with sexual immorality and pornography. Krista aggreed to give Enyart custody of their two boys. Enyarts second marriage would also end quickly in divorce.
During his TV show's nationwide run, Enyart married Cheryl Mayns, the ex-wife of a Jefferson County, Colorado sherriff's deputy. Enyart was charged in 1994 and ultimately convicted of misdemeanor child abuse in the striking of Mayns' son Steven (then age 7) with a belt, leaving bruises and welts on the boy's buttocks.
Enyart regained custody of his sons from his first marriage in 1999 after his ex-wife Krista died. They are involved with the design and operation of Enyart's websites. Enyart is currently the pastor of Denver Bible Church in Denver, Colorado.
Enyart is a self proclaimed right wing, religious fanatic, homophobic, anti-abortion. Enyart speaks his mind harshly, humorously and occasionally (and admittedly) disrespectfully where he deems appropriate. Enyart’s motto "Do right and risk the consequences" is indicative of his style of argument and evangelism, he prefers to speak what he believes to be truth, regardless of the possibility that he may offend, or worse.
He advocates for a Constitutional Monarchy under the leadership of a King, and would exclude a woman from becoming a regnant. In an article published in the Denver weekly newspaper Westword, Enyart said that "it's natural that men lead the household" and that households that are led by women turn out to be an "unhappy household." He also calls for the establishment of a criminal code under the Old Testament (or the Mosaic Law as Enyart likes to emphasize) as national law which includes the death penalty for offenses such as homosexuality, murder, attempted murder, adultery and abortion.
Homosexuality was frequently singled out for criticism by Enyart, who sold T-shirts imprinted with the slogan "Homos Make Me Sick", and once played the song by the rock band Queen "Another One Bites the Dust" as the names of AIDS victims scrolled by on the screen.
Enyart criticizes even the most right-wing conservatives, citing rulings and/or behaviors indicative of liberalism. He has openly denounced and rebuked right-wingers such as Supreme court judge Samuel Alito and Dr. James Dobson for allegedly compromising on various conservative values and engaging in Legal Positivism.
